Menu

Ethical and Environmental

Ethics and environment conflicts

Ethical considerations are about acting in ways stakeholders see as morally right, such as treating people fairly and honestly. Environmental considerations are about reducing harm to the natural world. They often overlap, but they can also conflict. A choice can be ethical but environmentally harmful, or environmentally friendly but unethical.

Ethical but not environmentally friendly

A clothing company might pay its factory workers a fair wage, give them safe conditions and refuse to use child labour. That is clearly ethical. However, it might fly its garments in from another country and use a fabric made from oil-based fibres. Air transport creates emissions and the fibres come from a non-renewable resource, so the same choice is environmentally harmful.

Environmentally friendly but not ethical

A bakery might buy organic flour grown with fewer chemical pesticides and deliver it in reusable crates. This reduces chemical use and packaging waste. But if the flour is harvested by workers paid very low wages and housed in poor conditions, the choice is environmentally friendly but unethical.

Weighing up the conflict

Because of these conflicts, a business cannot assume that an ethical decision is automatically environmentally friendly, or that an environmentally friendly decision is automatically ethical. It has to compare the two effects. For example, a manager may ask whether the damage from air freight is worse than the harm caused by switching to a supplier with poor working conditions. The business may look for a third option, such as a fairly paid supplier closer to home. Where no option removes the conflict, it must decide which concern its stakeholders value more and explain that choice.

Practise this